Passenger Pigeon

One of the most important and horrible stories of environmental degradation in the United States is the rapid decline of the passenger pigeon from perhaps the most common bird in North America to complete extinction in less than a century. We know why it happened–massive overhunting combined with the rapid loss of habitat as the fields were plowed up. Perhaps the most important representation of this in American culture is the scene in Cooper’s The Pioneers, where Natty Bumppo expressed extreme disgust over his neighbors’ wanton massacre of pigeons. But that never answered the question over why they went fully extinct instead of just became endangered like so many other species that later came back or at least have some level of population stability. There is some new evidence on this:

As co-author Beth Shapiro explains, the research — which involved studying a number of complete and mitochondrial passenger pigeon genomes, as well as genomes from a close relative, the band-tailed pigeon — overturns a previous theory about why passenger pigeons went extinct so quickly.

“A few years ago, a study was published that suggested that their populations actually fluctuated quite considerably over time and that this might have meant that they were already on a decline when humans turned up and started shooting them,” says Shapiro, an associate professor of ecology and evolutionary biology at the University of California, Santa Cruz. “And we found that this is, in fact, not true — that their populations had been extremely large and stable for at least the last several tens of thousands of years, even during the last ice age.”

Pigeons in these large, stable populations were well-adapted to life in big groups, Shapiro says. Individual pigeons likely didn’t have to work hard to find a mate, or worry as much about predation or finding food. But over the course of just several decades, she explains, our “industrial-scale murder” sharply reduced passenger pigeon numbers — and in smaller groups, the average passenger pigeon suddenly faced a host of new survival worries.

“If that ability had been lost over the course of tens of thousands of years of living in large populations, it would have been tough for them to survive as a tiny population,” she says.

For Shapiro, the passenger pigeon’s story is a cautionary tale — and a chance to learn from our misconceptions.

“We often think of things that are in large populations as being not particularly vulnerable to extinction, but perhaps that’s not true,” she says. “And perhaps when we’re thinking about whether a species is in danger of becoming extinct, we really need to think more holistically, start to consider the entire history of adaptation of that species.”

One similar population type could be fisheries, Shapiro says. “We know that fisheries have been very large, they tend to be large populations that are connected to each other,” she explains.

“And when we think about restoring them, we often don’t think about restoring them to these formerly enormous populations, but somehow being able to achieve smaller populations, potentially even isolated populations. But this may not be what these species really need to be able to come back.”

A cheery tale, just like everything else during the Sixth Extinction.